
CASE TITLE: JULIET v. OSEREMHEN (2026) LPELR-87237 (CA)
JUDGMENT DATE: 9TH OCTOBER, 2026
PRACTICE AREA: LAND LAW
LEAD JUDGMENT: BIOBELE ABRAHAM GEORGEWILL, J.C.A.
SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:
INTRODUCTION:
This appeal borders on proof of title to land.
FACTS:
This appeal is against the judgment of the High Court of Edo State.
According to the Respondent, the land in dispute was originally owned by one Pa. Ojienogho, who had at some time given it to his son as a gift, following the fulfilment of filial responsibilities. Thereafter, his son exercised various acts of ownership over the land in dispute, such as farming and giving it to another person to farm without recourse to his father, who was then still alive. However, the son sold the land to the Respondent, who proceeded to erect a low perimeter fence and foundation thereon, dug a soak – away pit, and left some blocks, as well as heaps of sand and stones on the land, and returned to his base in Lagos. Subsequently, the Appellant entered the land, laid additional layers of blocks on the perimeter fence built by the Respondent, closed the soak – away pit dug by the Respondent, constructed a fence on the front of the land, and installed a metallic gate in the front fence, hence the Respondent’s suit before the lower Court. The Appellant as Defendant/Counter – Claimant, however alleges that the son to Pa Ojienogho, and elder brother to Ehigie Ojienogho, the vendor to the Respondent, had transferred the land in dispute to her younger brother with the consent of all the sons of Pa Ojienogho, and to which Ehigie Ojienogho, the vendor to the Respondent, duly signed as a witness to Roman Ojienogho, the vendor to her younger brother. Subsequently, the Appellant’s younger brother made a gratuitous gift of the land in dispute to the Appellant, his elder sister, by virtue of which she became the owner of the land in dispute.
By a Writ of Summons, the Respondent, as Claimant, sought a declaration that the Appellant is a trespasser on the land, general damages and perpetual injunction restraining the Appellant. The Appellant filed a defence and counterclaim, also seeking declaratory relief, general damages and a counterclaim against the Respondent.
At the close of hearing, the Court delivered its judgment, in which it granted the Respondent’s claim for Declaration of title to the land in dispute and N2,000,000. 00 damages against the Appellant, while the Counter – claim of the Appellant against the Respondent was dismissed for lacking merit. The Appellant was dissatisfied with the said judgment and thus filed this appeal at the Court of Appeal.
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION:
The Court determined the appeal on the following issues:
1. Whether, considering the pleadings and the totality of the evidence on record, the lower Court was right to hold that the requirement of establishing how Pa Ojienogho came to own the land is dispensed with; and therefore, resolved the Respondent’s claim of possession in favor of the Respondent who established a better title to the disputed land?
2. Whether, from the totality of the evidence placed before the lower Court, the identity of the land in dispute was established?
3. Whether there is any substance in the Appellant’s complaint to this Court that the evidence led was not properly evaluated by the lower Court?
4. Whether from the pleadings of the Respondent and the evidence adduced before the lower Court, it was right for the lower Court to declare the activities of the Appellant on the land in dispute as acts of trespass and thereby award the sum of N2,000,000.00 as general damages against the Appellant?
DECISION/HELD:
The appeal was allowed.
RATIOS:
- EVIDENCE- BURDEN OF PROOF/ONUS OF PROOF: Whether a plaintiff/claimant/counter-claimant in an action for declaration of title to land must prove and rely on the strength of his case and not the weakness of the case of the defence
- EVIDENCE- ADMISSION/ADMITTED FACT(S): Whether admission/admitted facts need further proof
- EVIDENCE- EVALUATION OF EVIDENCE: Whether summary evidence led by the parties or re-statement of the evidence amounts to evaluation
- LAND LAW- IDENTITY OF LAND: Duty of a plaintiff/claimant to establish the identity/area of land in dispute; effect of failure to do same
- LAND LAW- IDENTITY OF LAND: Instances when identity of land will not be in issue and does not require proof
- LAND LAW- TRESPASS TO LAND: Whether a claim in trespass is based entirely on possession of the land
- LAND LAW- POSSESSION OF LAND: Effect of proof of better title against a party in possession of the land in dispute
To read the full judgment or similar judgments, subscribe to Prime or Primsol