
CASE TITLE: RACONTEUR PRODUCTIONS LTD v. DIONI VISION ENTERTAINMENT LTD & ORS (2026) LPELR 84522(CA)
JUDGMENT DATE: 16TH JULY, 2026
JUSTICES: YARGATA BYENCHIT NIMPAR, J. C. A.
MUSLIM SULE HASSAN, J. C. A.
PAUL AHMED BASSI, J. C. A.
PRACTICE AREA: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
FACTS:
This appeal borders on Intellectual Property Law.
This is an appeal against the judgment of the Federal High Court sitting at Lagos delivered by Hon. Justice I.N Buba, on the 2nd day of May, 2019.
The Appellant’s case was that PW2, Mr. Jude Odada, conceived and authored the screenplay titled “Okafor’s Law” and was engaged by the 1st and 2nd Respondents to develop the script for an agreed fee of N750,000. However, following his inability to reach the 1st and 2nd Respondents to secure payment, PW2 approached the Appellant, entered into a partnership with her and transferred the screenplay to her, upon which she acquired copyright protection over it. The Appellant subsequently entered into a partnership with the 3rd Respondent for the production of the movie. However, the 3rd Respondent terminated the partnership, and the Appellant later discovered that the 1st and 2nd Respondents had produced a movie bearing the same title and substantially similar characteristics, with the 3rd Respondent acting as its distributor. Consequently, the Appellant instituted the action alleging infringement of her copyright.
The 1st and 2nd Respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the idea for the screenplay originated from the 2nd Respondent and her husband, who had engaged PW2 to develop the script for the same agreed fee of N750,000. They contended that PW2 failed to deliver the script or remain reachable, prompting them to develop the movie themselves, which had already received international recognition before the Appellant instituted her action. The 3rd Respondent maintained that she was engaged by the 1st and 2nd Respondents solely to distribute their movie and terminated her earlier arrangement with the Appellant upon discovering that both arrangements concerned the same movie. The trial Court dismissed the Appellant’s claims for lack of merit, prompting this appeal.
ISSUES:
The merit of the appeal was determined based on the following issues:
1. Whether the lower Court was wrong to have held that the 1st and 2nd Respondents have the copyright to Okafor’s Law and that the 1st and 2nd Respondents did not infringe on the copyright of the Appellant?
2. Whether the Appellant led successful, succinct facts and credible evidence before the trial Court to establish the Appellant’s claim that the Respondents infringed on the copyright of the Appellant?
COUNSEL SUBMISSIONS:
The Appellant’s counsel submitted that the trial Judge erred in holding that the 1st and 2nd Respondents owned the copyright in “Okafor’s Law” and had not infringed the Appellant’s copyright. PW2 was the only person called as author of the screenplay, and the Respondents neither led evidence that they wrote it nor produced any other author. Having authored and fixed the screenplay in a definite medium, PW2 qualified for protection under Section 5(1)(a)(v) of the Copyright Act and, by Section 9(2), owned the copyright as author. With no finished contract between him and the 1st and 2nd Respondents, he was free to assign it to the Appellant. Counsel argued that merely discussing the idea of “Okafor’s Law” gave the Respondents no right over the screenplay, since the Act protects the expression of an idea, not the idea itself (citing the WIPO Copyright Treaty 1996, Zecola v Universal City Studios Inc (1982) 46 ALR 189 and Kenrick v Lawrence (1890) L.R 25 QBD). He added that the script and the film are separately protectable, and the claim was for exploitation of PW2’s script, not the film (LB (Plastics) Ltd v Swish Products Ltd (1979) RPC 531.). The Appellant’s case was that the screenplay, once exposed to the 3rd Respondent, was shared with the 1st and 2nd Respondents, who then produced the movie.
The 1st and 2nd Respondents’ counsel countered that the 2nd Respondent authored and owned the screenplay, having written it without any contribution from PW2. On PW2’s own evidence, corroborated by DW1, he never forwarded a script to her, and the only submission the Appellant made to the 3rd Respondent was a proposal for a different screenplay, “The Bet”. The allegation of collusion must fail because DW2 testified that the 3rd Respondent was never presented with any script titled “Okafor’s Law”, and the uncontroverted evidence of DW1 and DW2 must be taken as admitted, citing Ufikairo Monday Efet v. INEC & Ors (2011) 1 SCM 179 at 197. Counsel further submitted that the Respondents developed the screenplay themselves when PW2 could not be reached, produced the film and registered it with the National Film and Video Censors Board in September 2014 (Exhibit D4). To establish infringement, there must be access and copying, which the Appellant failed to prove.
Counsel to the 3rd Respondent submitted that the Appellant had failed to lead any evidence to substantiate her claim that the 1st and 2nd Respondents colluded with the 3rd Respondent to leak the screenplay of “Okafor Law’ and produce the movie.
DECISION/HELD:
The appeal was held to be lacking in merit and was accordingly dismissed.
RATIO:
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY- COPYRIGHT: Whether ideas are protected by copyright
“Copyright does not protect ideas, themes, concepts, folklore, plots in their general form, or basic story ideas. Instead, it protects the original way those ideas are expressed in a tangible form. See: UBOM V. GLOBACOM (NIG) LTD.
“Black’s Law Dictionary, 8th Edition, defines copyright thus: “The right to copy; specific property right in an original work or authorship (including literary, musical, dramatic, choreographic, pictorial, graphic, sculptural and architectural works; motion pictures and other audiovisual works and sound recordings) fixed in any tangible medium of expression, giving the holder the exclusive right to reproduce, adopt, distribute, perform and display the work. “In the explanatory notes it says: “What is copyright? “From copyright law’s beginnings close to three centuries ago, the term has meant just what it says: the right to make copies of a given work – at first it meant simply written work – and to stop others from making copies without one’s permission” – Paul Goldstein Copyright’s Highway 3 (1994) “From this definition, the copyright exists in the creative input into the work sought to be protected.”
This means that copyright protects the creator’s original expression of an idea, not the idea itself. Therefore, when two or more people discuss the same idea or draw inspiration from the same source, each person is free to create their own work based on that idea, as long as they do not copy another person’s original expression.” Per NIMPAR, J.C.A.
To read the full judgment or similar judgments, subscribe to Prime or Primsol