
CASE TITLE: WORGU & ANOR V. PROSPECTORS MARKETERS INTL LTD. & ANOR (2026) LPELR-84856(CA)
JUDGMENT DATE: 20TH JULY, 2026
PRACTICE AREA: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE
LEAD JUDGMENT: ADEBUKUNOLA ADEOTI IBIRONKE BANJOKO, J.C.A.
SUMMARY OF JUDGMENT:
INTRODUCTION:
This ruling is on an Application for Extension of Time and Stay of Proceedings.
FACTS:
By a Motion, the applicants sought orders of the Court extending time to apply for leave to appeal, granting leave to appeal, extending time to appeal, and staying of proceedings.
It was supported by an Affidavit to which several documentary exhibits were annexed, including the Proposed Notice of Appeal. The applicants also filed a Written Address in support of the Motion. The applicants also filed a further affidavit.
The 1st respondent opposed the application by filing a counter affidavit together with documentary exhibits. The applicants, in turn, reacted by filing a reply to the counter-affidavit.
The substantive action, which has remained pending before the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory since 2016, concerns a dispute between the parties over interests in land. During the course of the proceedings before the learned trial Judge, the claimant’s witness was under cross-examination by learned counsel representing the 2nd and 3rd defendants. According to the Applicants, the proceedings of that day were simultaneously audio-recorded by a representative of the defence team. Thereafter, upon obtaining what they believed to be the official record of proceedings, the applicants compared the contents thereof with the audio recording and formed the view that material portions of the oral testimony of the witness had not been faithfully reflected in the official record.
It was specifically alleged that portions of the witness’s testimony, which the applicants claimed were recorded by the Court, amounted to hearsay, and it was recorded as if they were corroborative evidence. This, in the applicants’ estimation, gave rise to grave apprehension that the record of proceedings no longer accurately reflected what transpired before the learned trial Judge, thereby creating a reasonable perception of bias and an apprehension that they would not receive a fair hearing before the Court. Acting upon that apprehension, the applicants approached the trial Court with an application requesting that the proceedings be transmitted to the Honourable Chief Judge of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory for re-assignment of the case to another judge.
That application was heard and, in a considered ruling delivered on the 25th day of February, 2026, the learned trial Judge declined the invitation to recuse herself or cause the matter to be re-assigned. Being dissatisfied with that interlocutory decision, the applicants resolved to challenge the same on appeal. However, due to several delays they were unable to file the appeal within time hence this application.
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION:
The Appeal was determined on a sole issue viz:
“Whether having regard to the affidavit evidence before this Court and the applicable principles of law, the applicants have established sufficient grounds to warrant the exercise of this Court’s discretionary jurisdiction in their favour.”
DECISION/HELD:
The Court refused the application.
RATIOS:
- APPEAL- INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL: Attitude of the Appellate Court to the filing of an interlocutory appeal when the substantive case is still pending
- APPEAL- EXTENSION/ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO APPEAL: Conditions to be satisfied by an applicant seeking extension of time to appeal and whether the conditions must co-exist
- APPEAL- EXTENSION/ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO APPEAL: What constitutes good and substantial reasons to grant extension of time to appeal
- COURT- DISCRETION OF COURT: How judicial discretion should be exercised
- PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE- RECORD OF COURT PROCEEDINGS: Importance of record of proceedings; whether a party challenging the correctness of a record of proceedings can predicate an appeal on same
- PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE- RECORD OF COURT PROCEEDINGS: Duty on the party challenging the contents of the record of proceedings
To read the full judgment or similar judgments, subscribe to Prime or Primsol